Don’t Buy our Product?

While the majority of retailers were busy sending out email blasts promoting their Cyber Monday deals in the hopes of increasing sales, Patagonia took a dramatically different approach.  Recipients on Patagonia’s email list received the following message, demanding that they not purchase a Patagonia jacket on Cyber Monday.

As part of their Common Threads Initiative, Patagonia hoped to encourage consumers to think about the environment and over-consumption before purchasing anything on Cyber Monday.  The Common Threads program aims to reduce consumption of the environment by making all Patagonia items 100% recyclable.  Consumers are encouraged to turn in their worn out Patagonia items in the store before purchasing additional merchandise.  These items then get sent to refurbishment centers where they are processed and turned into new Patagonia products.  The statement released by Patagonia on Cyber Monday stated:

“Cyber Monday, and the culture of consumption it reflects, puts the economy of natural systems that support all life firmly in the red. We’re now using the resources of one-and-a-half planets on our one and only planet.

Because Patagonia wants to be in business for a good long time – and leave a world inhabitable for our kids – we want to do the opposite of every other business today. We ask you to buy less and to reflect before you spend a dime on this jacket or anything else.”

While protecting the environment is a very important issue and one that Patagonia fully supports, their Cyber Monday email was also a disguised marketing campaign.  After all, Patagonia is a company and companies need to sell their products in order to stay viable.

First of all, by bringing awareness to their cause, Patagonia is aligning themselves with a large segment of their target consumer.  We know that people have a more positive attitude about people or companies that they feel share similar values with themselves.  Therefore, people who are also concerned about protecting the environment will likely have a positive attitude about Patagonia and be more likely to purchase products from them in the future.  Jackets and outdoor wear sold by stores like Patagonia aren’t typically viewed as impulse Internet buys like electronics and other products.  In an attempt to stand out from the barrage of Cyber Monday impulse advertising by other retailers, Patagonia used this opportunity to be noticed by making a bold statement in the hopes of boosting sales as they enter the winter and holiday season.

Patagonia’s ad campaign is actually quite clever.  By telling consumer’s not to buy something, it might actually increase sales of that product.  This counterintuitive phenomenon can be explained by the theory of psychological reactance.  Psychological reactance is an emotional reaction to the elimination of behavioral freedoms.  People like to feel like they have choices and freedom, therefore when they are told that they can’t have something, it often increases the attractiveness of that product.  Telling its customers not to purchase their jacket might actually increase people’s desire to have that jacket even without their awareness.

Lastly, the design of the message clearly features the Patagonia jacket like most product advertisements would.  As seen above, the image is simple – plain black font with a picture of a new vibrant blue jacket.  Due to the color and size of the jacket compared to the rest of the message, your eye is first drawn to the jacket before even reading the message.  If this message were solely meant to bring awareness to the Common Threads Initiative and encourage people not to consume as much on Cyber Monday, Patagonia could have used other images like the image shown below of discarded clothing that is on their website.  However, they wanted to showcase their product and draw the consumer’s awareness to it.  And, we know that mere exposure can create a consumer’s positive attitude about a product, which in turn leads to increased probability of the consumer purchasing that product as well.

 I am not at all trying to detract from Patagonia’s Common Threads Initiative or message – they are a great company pursuing a very worthy cause…and they are very clever marketers.   I found this anti-purchase ad to really stand out from the crowd especially on a day like Cyber Monday when my inbox was flooded with emails from retailers pushing their products.  What appears to be a bold statement against buying their products is in fact a creative marketing campaign that employs psychology to raise awareness of their cause and boost sales of their products in this time of advertising overload.

In the Spirit of Holiday Travel

With the holidays just around the corner and everyone gearing up for their holiday travels, Spirit Airlines has just announced that they are going to start charging $34 to book a domestic round trip flight online.  Spirit Airlines, the Florida based airline that promotes itself as the ultra low budget airline, has one of the most extensive extra fee lists of any airline.  Sure, when searching Expedia, you may think you’re getting a really good fare on Spirit compared to the other airlines, but don’t forget about the new $34 online booking fee, $10 reservation fee and $16.99 passenger usage fee.  And unless you’re going on a day trip, you probably have luggage – that will be another $20-$35 for one carry-on and $18-$33 for your first checked bag.  You’re hungry or thirsty on your flight?  That will cost you too – there are no complimentary beverages or snacks (not even water).  Oh, and did I mention that the only way to avoid the new online booking fee is to book your flight at the airport counter, but starting January 24, 2012, they will charge you $5 to print your ticket at the counter.  Bottom line, it adds up.

Long gone are the days when people choose their flights based on the amenities offered by certain airlines or their loyalty to a specific airline.  Airline deregulation brought us lower airfares and travel comparison websites like Kayak and Expedia have brought us the ability to search for the lowest cost possible for travel to our destination.  On these websites, having the lowest fares compared to competing airlines is very important and this is what Spirit capitalizes on.  The contrast effect shows that a fare that is cheaper than all other fares will be viewed as an especially good deal in contrast to the more expensive fares.  Therefore, people will choose this cheaper fare even if it does not include all the additional “optional” fees and that is where airlines, like Spirit get you.  Spirit’s pricing model is an example of “drip pricing” – pricing where the actual total price of the purchase is only revealed at the end of the purchasing process after a number of compulsory and hidden fees have been added on.  However, from a psychological standpoint, this may be an effective way of marketing, especially with online purchases.  Typically, the total price isn’t shown until the very end of the purchasing process after consumers have already filled out a number of web pages with their personal information, billing information, etc.  At this point, the consumer has pretty much already committed to the purchase and we know that people like to appear consistent, even if no one else is around.  Once they commit to a decision, people are much more likely to follow through with the behavior in an effort to remain consistent.  Additionally, effort justification may cause people to rationalize any cognitive dissonance they may feel about the increase in price compared to the good deal they thought they were getting – “this fare was so much lower than all the other airlines so I’m still getting a good deal!”  Lastly, once you’ve purchased your ticket, what choice do you really have about some of the fees like the baggage fees and food/drink fees?  You’re not going to leave your luggage at home for a week-long trip just to avoid additional baggage fees.  And, besides, other airlines charge for baggage too, right? The airlines know this and that drives their pricing and marketing strategy.  Show the lowest possible fare and then make up the cost through extra fees once the passenger is committed.

Air travel is no longer viewed as a luxury and more as a means to get from one location to another.  However, can Spirit’s ultra low budget method harm them?  Just as people often follow the stereotype of “expensive = good” when selecting a wine, conversely when it comes to airline travel, ultra low budget can imply poor service, poorly maintained aircraft and an unpleasant travel experience.  It will be interesting to see if, over the long term, people still fall for the low prices of Spirit Airlines or whether all the additional fees will deter people from booking with Spirit.

I’m Shocked…

Recently, Richard Leon, a federal judge, ruled that forcing tobacco companies to place health warnings that included pictures of cadavers and diseased lungs on their packaging violates the 1st Amendment Rights of the tobacco companies.  Judge Leon went on to say that the “images went beyond disseminating ‘purely factual and unconventional info’ and ventured into advocacy.”  This ruling was made in response to legal actions brought against the FDA by a number of tobacco companies resulting from a FDA sponsored law enacted by Congress in 2009 which was supposed to go into effect in September 2011.  Obviously, the FDA was  hoping to scare people into not buying tobacco products by requiring graphic images on tobacco packaging.  All of which raises the question:  what are shock campaigns and are they an effective form of marketing?

Shock advertising, also referred to as Shockvertising, is a type of advertising that deliberately startles and offends its audience.  It achieves this by violating social norms and personal ideas.  In addition to being offensive,  the information is often times frightening and controversial.  Benneton, an Italian clothes retailer, is considered the originator of shock advertising when they ran ads in the late 1980’s, which showcased various images about HIV/AIDS.  Everyday, consumers are bombarded with advertisements in all aspects of their lives.  One of the main purposes of shock advertising is to cut through the rest of the advertising “clutter” and to stand out among the crowd by capturing the audience’s attention with graphic images or blunt slogans.

Research conducted on shock advertising has found that using shocking content in ads does “increase attention, benefits memory and positively influences behavior.”  One reason for this could be that shocking ads evoke stronger feelings among consumers and therefore they notice and remember the message more strongly.  Relating to the current situation with the tobacco companies, James Wheaton, a 1st Amendment expert at UC Berkley, states –  “You can’t force a company to carry the government’s opinion on an issue.  These images are clearly not limited to a statement of fact. They’re designed to evoke an emotional response.”  It is precisely this emotional response that the FDA is trying to capitalize on in getting their anti-smoking message across.

The effectiveness of shock advertising can also be explained by the theory of selective perception.  According to this theory, individuals choose and evaluate stimuli from the external environment based on what is meaningful to them.  This focus on certain features to the exclusion of others occurs without awareness and is filtered based on earlier experiences.  Therefore, shocking advertisements could either increase or decrease a behavior depending on the recipient of the message.  If an individual feels like the message is beneficial, it may stick out in their minds and they may remember it better.  On the other hand, if an individual finds the message to be threatening or disturbing to them, they may filter the message out.  For example, in the current situation, a heavy smoker may ignore the picture of diseased lungs on the cigarette packaging because this image is seen as disturbing to them and could lead to cognitive dissonance.

Shock advertising has benefits in getting a message to stand out and be more easily remembered.  Historically, anti-smoking campaigns capitalize on shock advertising by showing graphic images such as a woman smoking out of a hole in her throat and bodies in body bags, which are meant to frighten its audience.  While it is important to spread the message about the dangers of smoking, especially to children, requiring companies to employ shock advertising against their own product on their packaging does seem to violate 1st Amendment Rights.  The FDA may wish to continue the use of shock advertising in their campaign against smoking but requiring marketers of tobacco products to incorporate anti-smoking shock ads on their packaging is just plain wrong.

—

Article

Food Fight: Should Food Companies be Allowed to Market to Children?

Does marketing contribute to childhood obesity?  With one third of US children classified as either overweight or obese, the debate over food marketer’s responsibility for this phenomenon is heating up.  Critics are painting a bull’s eye on food marketers as the main culprit in causing childhood obesity.  Others argue that the combination of marketing unhealthy food to children, parent’s inability to say “no” to their children and general lack of exercise are all contributing factors to this growing problem.  Recently, the debate has focused on whether food companies should even be allowed to market to children.  One side argues that restrictions should be imposed on the marketing of unhealthy foods that are aimed directly at children, while the other side of the argument believes that the only solution is a complete ban on marketing towards children.

The Interagency Working Group was formed in 2009 to try and develop nutritional guidelines for foods marketed towards children.  The Federal Trade Commission has recently joined the Interagency Working group in an effort to develop standards for self-regulation within the industry.   The proposed voluntary guidelines would cause companies to reduce the sugar, fat and salt and increase healthy nutrients in foods they wish to market to children.  Currently, about one third of the foods marketed to children would not pass these guidelines. However, many companies, like McDonalds, have come out with their own standards to make children’s food healthier.  For example, McDonalds now includes the option of apple slices instead of French Fries as part of the Happy Meal.

Critics who oppose guidelines for the voluntary self-regulation within the industry argue that marketing towards children should be banned all together.  This side argues that voluntary guidelines do not make economic sense for companies and therefore the industry won’t be responsible for establishing and following guidelines that conflict with their economic interests.  Companies know that junk food — foods that contain high levels of sugar, salt and fat — sells and therefore, these are the products that they advertise.  Critics of industry self-regulation believe that banning marketing altogether is the only option in our efforts to reduce childhood obesity.  Instead, they believe that food marketing should be aimed at parents and they can and should be the ones who decide what their children eat.  This side also believes that banning marketing to children will make the food industry a more level playing field – companies that want to produce nutritionally healthy food won’t be placed at a competitive disadvantage.  However, it can be argued that companies that market “junk food” will now be placed at a competitive disadvantage, since parents are more likely to pick the more nutritious food for their children.

From a psychological standpoint, there are a number of reasons why the traditional marketing of food products is successful.  First of all, children are a lot more easily persuaded than adults and an attractive TV commercial can easily sway their attitudes about certain products.  Also, the fact that many food companies offer prizes or toys in their products can increase motivation to purchase these products.  These toys serve as incentives and make the products more attractive.  Lastly, many food companies use popular cartoon characters in their marketing campaigns.  Like celebrity endorsements, these cartoon characters serve as spokespeople for the product and due to the balance theory, children are more likely to like a certain product if they see a character they like “using” that product.

It is clear that there is an increasing problem with childhood obesity in the United States and the food industry’s marketing to children plays a role in the foods they choose to eat.  Most of the food commercials on TV are advertising “junk food.”  However, I don’t think that banning all marketing to children is the solution.  In fact, banning marketing to children would work against a company’s economic best interest.  Instead, I think that guidelines should be implemented to promote more nutritional options to children.  Industry self-regulation may in fact work if companies implement some of the strategies they currently use like incentives and “celebrity” spokespeople in an effort to promote more nutritional food options for children.  Why not have a popular cartoon character advertise oatmeal instead of a sugary cereal?  By capitalizing on the psychology behind marketing, we may be able to change the eating habits of children and reduce childhood obesity.

The “MAGIC” behind Celebrity Branding Deals

Celebrity endorsements are everywhere we look and cover a multitude of products from clothing to sports drinks to medicine.  Just a few of the places we constantly see celebrity endorsements are on TV, in magazines, and billboards.  We know that celebrity endorsements can be very beneficial to a company.  However, I never really took the time to think about how these branding relationships come about.  I always assumed that these partnerships between celebrities and companies were formed by one party calling up the other party and expressing interest in forming a relationship.  I recently read an interesting LA Times article that discussed the sophisticated marketing efforts behind these deals.  Sure, some deals are formed by one party reaching out to the other, but in what seems to be a relatively recent phenomenon, concerted, precisely planned events are being organized to bring celebrities together with a large number of products and brands.  One of the most prominent of such events is the Sundance Film Festival in Park City, Utah.

Many of these branding events are organized by two LA natives – Michael Baruch, Fred Segal Beauty cofounder, and Jeffrey Best, an event planner.  Baruch and Best realized that the multi-day Sundance Film Festival presented a perfect environment to create branding opportunities between celebrities, and products and companies.  The Sundance Film Festival brings together a powerful mix of celebrities in one place at the same time, so Baruch and Best arranged for companies to bring their products and brands to the celebrities and organized events to foster new connections.

More recently, Baruch and Best planned a branding lunch in Las Vegas to accompany the MAGIC apparel trade show, a biannual 3-day event.  In essence, this situation was the reverse of Sundance – the products and companies were all in one place, so Baruch and Best focused on bringing celebrities to Las Vegas.  Along with Advanstar Communications, who owns the MAGIC trade show, Baruch and Best organized a branding luncheon to bring together the celebrities with the products and companies.  Every detail of the event was carefully planned to facilitate creating relationships between the celebrities and companies.  The luncheon had 15 tables of 10 guests and each table was organized to pair specific brands with celebrities.  As Joe Loggia, the CEO of Advanstar, said, “There’s no random anywhere.”  For instance, they knew that Jennifer Love Hewitt was interested in a beauty deal, so they sat her at a table next to someone in the beauty industry.  These events are proving to be successful in creating contacts and relationships between celebrities and brands.  Cedric the Entertainer recently launched a line of hats with the help of a company he met at one of these branding lunches.

Psychologically, we know that celebrity endorsements can prove to be very beneficial to companies and products.  Fritz Heider’s Balance Theory explains the effectiveness of celebrity endorsements when a well-liked celebrity uses a product.  The balance theory states that people like balance in their lives and if they have a positive attitude towards a celebrity and they see that celebrity using a certain product or service, then they will likely have a positive attitude toward the product or service as well.  The Principle of Attractiveness says that people are more likely to listen to a message from someone they find attractive. Thus, having an attractive celebrity deliver a brand’s message may broaden the audience and increase the chance of the message being heard and remembered.  Lastly, having a celebrity promote a product can increase the familiarity of that product and the Principle of Familiarity and the Mere Exposure Effect states that people are more attracted to things that are more familiar to them.  Conversely, a celebrity with a poor image can damage harm a brand.  This is why we see celebrities losing endorsement deals when they are involved in a public or personal scandal.  We saw this happen with Tiger Woods – companies he had endorsements with quickly withdrew their relationships with him as his personal transgressions were exposed.

Branding relationships between a company and a celebrity can be extremely beneficial to both parties if they are both viewed in a positive light and Baruch and Best have hit on a great strategy to facilitate these connections.  I’ll be curious to see how popular these branding events become to create branding relationships between celebrities and brands as competition heats up for both celebrities and product marketers.

Will Humor Sell Personal Injury Law Services?

“Remember that guy? Who came in second in the last New York Marathon? Neither do we. Winning is everything.” (Commercial)

Catches your attention, no?  This is the script of one of the new commercials aired by Jacoby and Meyers, a full-service law firm.  In a new marketing campaign, Jacoby and Meyers is taking a notably different approach to their personal injury practice TV advertisements than they have in the past.  We’ve all seen the advertisements for personal injury lawyers (and probably rolled our eyes at them) where a tough talking lawyer informs us that we have options if we’ve been injured in an accident and then promises us revenge and justice if we just call their office.  By now, most people don’t pay much attention to these advertisements since all of them seem the same and have the same message, regardless of the law firm.  For the majority of the population, they probably aren’t even relevant anyway.  Psychology shows that people are much more likely to listen to a message and be receptive to a message if it personally relates to them.  Therefore, due to the repetitive nature and lack of relevance, most people probably tune these commercials out.  However, by changing the message and format of their advertisements and adding in some humor, Jacoby and Meyers can potentially separate themselves from the other advertisers and stimulate renewed attention to their message.

Rather than having a tough talking lawyer assault you from the TV screen, the 3 new Jacoby and Meyers commercials are devoid of people.  They are comprised of a simple black background with clever statements in white lettering; the advertising message is narrated by a male voice with music playing in the background.  What stands out the most in these commercials from previous Jacoby and Meyers commercials is that they employ humor in their messages.  In addition to the commercial message described at the beginning of this blog, another commercial shows portraits of the historical figures Horatio Seymour, Charles C. Pinckney, Hugh L. White and Lewis Cass (all losing opponents in Presidential elections) while “Hail to the Chief” plays in the background.  Then, a voice says “Presidential elections are like lawsuits.  You’re nobody unless you win.”  The third commercial states, “They say it doesn’t matter if you win or lose.  As long as you tried your best. They probably weren’t rear-ended by a truck.”  By adding humor to their commercials, Jacoby and Meyers is trying to humanize their message and  they are making  it more personal to the consumer while trying to set their message apart from other personal injury law firms by presenting a novel approach.  This should increase consumer’s awareness of their services and make it more prominent in their memories.  Lastly, Jacoby and Meyers may be employing humor to catch the consumer’s attention so that they will pay attention to the message.  And, as we know, mere exposure increases a person’s positive attitude toward that product or service.  This is commonly seen in insurance commercials – they employ humor to get consumers to pay attention to what would otherwise be a boring message.  An insurance company that employs this tactic is Geico with their Geico Gecko.

These three commercials are also trying to appeal more directly to the consumer.  Potential clients in personal injury lawsuits are interested in success, so all of the messages are focused on “Winning.”  By humanizing the message and relating it more directly to potential clients, Jacoby and Meyer’s is increasing the chance that their message will be viewed in a favorable light and will be remembered by consumers.  Lastly, the “Marathon” and “They say” commercials are noticeably shorter, 16 and 17 seconds in length respectively, than the average TV commercial including past Jacoby and Meyer’s commercials.  The shorter duration might increase the likelihood that viewers will watch the entire commercials.

While I don’t know how successful these commercials will be in the long run, Jacoby and Meyer’s new marketing approach definitely sets them apart from the advertisements of other similar firms.  I am much more apt to watch these commercial (at least for a couple of times) than their old ones because they are clever and novel.  The novelty of these specific commercials may sizzle out, but if Jacoby and Meyers can continue to come up with clever statements, they may find marketing success.

Great Expectations?

My mom recently related a conversation that she and a friend had about how they decided what movies to see.  My mom will look up movie reviews online before selecting which movie to go to, whereas her friend will choose a movie if there is an actor or actress she really likes, regardless of whether it received good reviews.  She went on to say that she was rarely disappointed when she went to see movies with her favorite actor or actress. Even if the movie wasn’t great and had received bad reviews, she didn’t have high expectations of it going in and thus she was able to enjoy the movie more than if she expected to see a great movie.  Hearing this conversation got me thinking about expectations and how companies manage expectations about their products.  When launching a new product, of course, companies want consumers to be excited about their product but should they be concerned about building too much hype about their product and risk having consumers be disappointed?

A recent example of this challenge was Apple’s introduction of the new iPhone 4s last week.  For the past year, rumors have been swirling about Apple’s new iPhone 5 which was expected to incorporate the latest 4g internet capabilities. So, when Apple delayed the release of its new phone to Fall 2011, the public’s expectations were further heightened as social and traditional media outlets buzzed about the iPhone 5.  However, Apple didn’t introduce the 4g internet capable iPhone5 last week – instead, announcing the iPhone 4s, a phone that looks the same as the iPhone 4 but with some improved technology.  There has been lots of talk about consumer’s being disappointed with this announcement despite the fact that more than 1 million units of the new iPhone 4s were pre-ordered within the first 24 hours.  So, we are faced with the question of whether Apple failed to meet consumers’ expectations and even more importantly, should they have done a better job of managing consumer expectations to avoid disappointment?  Traditionally, Apple has done an extraordinary job of managing expectations – they consistently follow the policy of under promising and then over delivering.  Although they like to appear silent and secretive, in the past, Apple has strategically leaked information to trusted media sources in an effort to adjust the expectations of consumers prior to new product announcements.

Expectations influence people’s motivation both intrinsically and extrinsically.  From a personal standpoint, people are motivated to do things and purchase products that they find satisfying, enjoyable, novel or those that they get rewards from.  Therefore, consumers often have expectations about what they will get out of an experience or product ahead of time.  Failure to live up to these expectations results in disappointment while things that exceed expectations result in increased satisfaction.

As a company or marketer, it is important to get consumers excited about your product, however, you don’t want to create too much hype so as to create disappointment in your product if it doesn’t live up to consumers’ expectations.  While there is no magic formula for how to strike this balance, perhaps the best plan is to do like Apple has done in the past – under promise and then over deliver.  This strategy will typically cause consumers to have an even more positive reaction to the new product or service as their expectations are exceeded.  It isn’t clear why Apple didn’t mange consumer expectations more before last week’s announcement, since managing consumer’s expectations about their products has been a successful marketing technique in the past.  Was it a lapse in strategy without the maestro’s touch or could it be Apple’s marketing genius at work to reset our expectations for new Apple products?

Rolling to Success

Food trucks have been around for a long time, but they are no longer just a place to get a greasy grilled cheese or hamburger.  Today, food trucks offer us an endless array of gourmet options from lobster rolls to Kogi BBQ.  Food trucks offer relatively inexpensive but delicious food and they are fun to visit as well (the long lines just make your food taste even better when you get it, right?).  However, I never really thought of the business benefits food trucks create.  The LA Times recently featured an article about how many food truck owners opened up food trucks to pilot their menus and gain exposure before opening up sit-down restaurants.  What a great idea!

Food trucks are cheaper to start up and operate than a brick-and-mortar business; overhead and operating costs are lower and the risks associated with starting a business are not nearly as high, especially in the current economic conditions.  The cost of opening a small restaurant can easily top $400,000, while opening a larger restaurant can run into the millions and the risks are huge – you don’t know if people are going to like what you have to offer.  On the other hand, a used food truck can be purchased for around $20,000 and while you also don’t know if people will like what you have to offer, the overhead, operating costs and amount of effort needed to get the business rolling is much lower.

The majority of advertising for food trucks is free – Facebook, Twitter and word of mouth.  In essence though, the truck itself is great advertising.  Since the truck is driven from location to location, the truck itself can serve as a moving billboard and its product is exposed to many more people than would probably drive by a single brick-and-mortar location.  Psychology shows that based on the mere exposure effect, people tend to have more positive attitudes about things to which they have been exposed, even if the exposure occurred unconsciously.  People also have more positive attitudes about things they see as familiar.  In addition to creating exposure and familiarity, people by nature are curious and seeing a “branded” food truck driving around might make them wonder what kinds of food the truck has to offer.  I, for one, have gone home and looked up food trucks I’ve seen driving on the freeway.

Popular food trucks gain large followings through social media and word of mouth.  This is a huge benefit to any business that starts out as a truck and then expands to a restaurant, because they have hundreds of potential patrons before they even open their doors.  As Eric Tjahyadi, co-owner of the Komodo Truck and Komodo Café, said, “The food truck is an engine for validation.”  Essentially, most of the marketing and advertising for a new restaurant has already been done by just having the food truck driving around; the menu can be validated and the risks associated with start-up can be mitigated all while satisfying people’s appetites.  Lastly, the long lines seen in front of popular food trucks can actually be beneficial in attracting customers.  Often times, people rely on heuristics when forming an attitude about something they don’t have much knowledge about.  Therefore, if people see a long line, they are more likely to arrive at the conclusion that the food must be good since so many people are waiting for it and get in line to try it for themselves.  Although, I’ve always wondered why it is that people are more likely to wait in a 45 minute line for a food truck than for a table at a restaurant?  Perhaps it has to do with the “uniqueness” of the modern food truck concept.

Whether food trucks are just a fad or are here to stay, their current popularity presents interesting advertising and marketing alternatives for restauranteurs .  With extensive opportunities to capitalize on the power of social media and utilize traveling “billboards” for product branding, the modern food truck has become a cost-effective option to opening a brick-and mortar restaurant.  Their mobility provides great exposure for their product and allows people to become familiar with their company even if they haven’t gotten the chance to try the food yet.  As their popularity increases with the number of consumers who try their food, a loyal following can be easily translated into restaurant patrons when and if the time comes to establish a restaurant.  The relative low cost of operating a food truck is also a great way to test out menus and brand the product before committing to a sit-down restaurant.

Unfortunately, “Kara’s Cupcakes” already exists (image).  Guess I will have to do some more brainstorming before hitting the road with a food truck!

LA Times article

Facebook Timeline: Good or Bad for Marketing?

Ever since Facebook’s Timeline feature was announced at the F8 conference on September 22, everywhere we turn, we are bombarded by articles about the Timeline feature.  This is a big change for Facebook and people are more than willing to give their opinions about this change — some people think its great while others are less than thrilled – we’ve heard it all.  However, what does this new feature mean for brands and marketers?

Until now, companies and brands created fan pages and then tried to get as many people to “Like” their page as possible, often times by offering incentives to those who became fans of their page.  While the number of “Likes” wasn’t truly indicative of how successful a company was at marketing their product or service, it was the measure of marketing success for many companies.  However, with the new changes to Facebook, the “Like” button will play a smaller role and advertisers and marketers will be forced to come up with more compelling content to have consumers pay attention to their brand.  One of the major disadvantages under this new system is that consumer’s are able to uncheck stories in their newsfeed that they don’t find interesting and over time, Facebook will only display stories that it thinks will be of interest to that person.  This means that companies and brands must deliver new and interesting content to keep their brand in consumer’s news feeds.  Based on the psychological principle of familiarity and the mere exposure effect, we know that people are more attracted to things that they are familiar with even if this exposure occurs in a subconscious manner.  Thus, not having your company or brand appear in consumer’s newsfeeds could be very detrimental.  As Eric Johnson, the President and Founder of Ignited, a marketing agency, said, “It’s clear that consumers are in control, and they will increasingly only invite marketing and brands that they choose to bring into their life.” (quote)

Facebook’s Timeline is focused on the idea of trying to gather a user’s whole life story and companies and brands will have to figure out a way to integrate themselves into the consumer’s life story.  Marketers will be forced to come up with ways to have consumers engage in branded actions for their products through Facebook.  It is now more about connecting with the consumer and becoming a part of their life.  In a way, Timeline can humanize brands as the message becomes more authentic, and make the consumer feel more in touch with the brand or company.  This idea is supported psychologically —  people are more likely to listen to and process a message if they feel like the message is relevant to them.  People are also more likely to pay attention to a message they see as authentic and genuine.  Brand pages will now be less about selling and more about telling a story about the brands and products.

A major advantage of the Timeline feature for brands and companies is that the pages themselves will be more customizable and companies will be able to create a more “branded” page.  A major feature of the Timeline is photos and all brand pages will have a customizable header at the top of the page rather than the generic page with just a profile picture that is offered now.  Additionally, the new brand pages are easier to navigate, information will be easier to find and pages will contain more content.  In this way, the brand pages should be more interesting and will lead to more engaging content for consumers – “Brands can express what makes them unique and build an emotional connection with fans.” (quote) Engaging consumers and building connections with them increases the consumer’s likelihood of using that product or service.

While marketers and companies may be forced to work harder to engage their consumers by creating high quality and compelling content, I think that Facebook’s Timeline will be more beneficial than the current fan pages for brands and companies who make an effort to integrate themselves into their consumer’s lives.  What do you think?

How Effective is Peer Pressure in Social Media?

In this age of social media, user reviews and recommendations are everywhere we look.  You can read other consumer’s opinions on practically any product on the market from toothpaste to travel destinations.  How influential are other consumer’s opinions and do they really cause us to change our minds about products?  A new study conducted by the HP Labs shows that peer pressure in social media is indeed effective and can have important implications for online marketing.  However, this study indicates that peer pressure in social media is more effective in reversing decisions when fewer people disagree than when many people disagree.

The study conducted by the HP Labs showed participants a picture of two loveseats on a computer screen.  Under the pictures, was the sentence “Your close friend wants your opinion on a loveseat for their living room.  Which do you suggest?”  Participants were asked to select their preference by clicking a button under the loveseat of their choice.  After varying intervals of time, participants were then shown the same items again and asked to make their selection again.  However, this time, participants were told that a varying number of other people had preferred the opposite loveseat than the one they had chosen.  The findings from this study showed that people were more likely to change their decision if only a moderate number of people had chosen the opposite loveseat versus a large number of people opposing their decision.  The study also found that people were more likely to change their decision when there was a greater interval of time passing between the two decision points versus people who were asked to make the decision again immediately after their initial decision.  Lastly, participants were more likely to reverse their initial decision if they spent more time making the initial decision than those who spent less time making the initial decision.

When it comes to the effectiveness of peer pressure in social media, this study illustrates two psychological principles, which contradict each other.  The principle of social influence and conformity occurs when an individual’s thoughts, feelings and actions are affected by other’s thoughts, feelings and actions; people will often change their own attitudes and beliefs to fit in with a group and conform to social norms.  I think a situation like the one presented in the study could lead to public compliance, where the participant conforms publicly to fit in but still privately holds to their initial beliefs, because disagreeing with the group regarding loveseat preference does not cause much cognitive dissonance.  The other principle we see in this study is the reactance theory.  Once we make a decision and commit to it, we don’t like to be self-contradictory and therefore when we face opposition to our beliefs, the need for self-preservation causes us to stick to them more strongly and increases our resistance to persuasion.  This can help explain why people were less likely to reverse their decision when a large number of people chose the opposite loveseat – there was a bigger threat and therefore a greater need for self-preservation.  The fact that people who spent a shorter amount of time making their initial decision were less likely to reverse their decision when asked again could be an indication of attitude strength and accessibility – the stronger an attitude is, the less time it will take to respond and the more stable it is over time.

This study has important implications for marketing and indicates that the power of persuasion and peer pressure from a few individuals is much more effective than peer pressure from many.  As a marketer, if you want to convince people to change their opinions and beliefs, it is best not to make their initial decision seem incredibly unpopular, otherwise they will become more determined to stick to their initial assessment of your product.  Bernardo Huberman, co-author of the current study, summed up this idea when he said “Rather than overwhelming consumers with strident messages about an alternative product or service, in social media, gentle reporting of a few people having chosen that product or service can be more persuasive.”

—

PDF of the full study